Sponsored: Should I eat like my great-grandmother?

Ask Leah! The Ingles Dietitian

Sponsored: Should I eat like my great-grandmother?

Question: What do you think of trying to “eat the way my great-grandmother ate”?

Answer: I call brief messages about food or nutrition that sound good or look good in print “soundbite nutrition”.

In June of 2006 Michael Pollan wrote an article in Time Magazine, "Six Rules for Eating Wisely" and cautioned, "Don’t eat anything your great-great-great grandmother wouldn’t recognize as food." By January 2007 (a mere six month later) in a New York Times Magazine article entitled "Unhappy Meals" (http://michaelpollan.com/articles-archive/unhappy-meals) Pollan had revised that a generation and advised "Eat Food: ..... Don’t eat anything your great-great-grandmother wouldn’t recognize as food."

By April of 2008 Mr. Pollan gave an interview to NPR (http://www.npr.org/templates/story/story.php?storyId=89876927) and had again dropped a generation and was now advising, "... If your great-grandmother wouldn't recognize it as food, then neither should you" .

Just think about all of the foods that those women never saw that many now eat on a regular basis... edamame, mango, kiwi, papaya, bananas…. Read about my interview with seniors aged 71-95 years old (http://inglesnutrition.blogspot.com/2015/09/many-of-us-have-probably-read.html) and you’ll learn that for many citrus fruit was a rare treat and most didn’t have freezers.

So before you embrace a simplistic nutrition message stop and think about it for a few minutes!

Related Items

Leah McGrath, RDN, LDN

Ingles Markets Corporate Dietitian

twitter.com/InglesDietitian

facebook.com/LeahMcgrathDietitian

800-334-4936

Tags:

Up Moses Creek: 2 a.m.

A sudden, loud crack came through the open bedroom...

Up Moses Creek: Coyote Howl

I was hiking in the woods above our house at ...

The Joyful Botanist: After The Flood

Water washes us clean, helps to cook our food and ...

Notes from a plant nerd: Like a podium

Creeping along the forest floor is a group of nati...

SUPPORT THE SMOKY MOUNTAIN NEWS AND
INDEPENDENT, AWARD-WINNING JOURNALISM

Contribute >

Ask Leah! The Ingles Dietitian

Partner content: Dinner — Something for Everyone?

Whether it’s a family gathering or a co-worker get together, what kind of meal can you make that will please everyone?

Ask Leah! The Ingles Dietitian

Partner content: Stories of dining during a disaster

Hurricane Helene was and continues to be a traumatic event for our region, but even within the worst of it, there are stories of resilience and ingenuity in ways that many had to deal with making or getting meals while having no power or water for days.

Ask Leah! The Ingles Dietitian

Partner content: Ways to (Continue to) Help Western NC

There are many churches and community relief and service organizations that are and will continue to help in the wake of Hurricane Helene. Please make sure you check on what local area churches may be doing or need in terms of donations. Money is often the best thing to donate so they can buy what they need. Volunteer time is also often appreciated.

Ask Leah! The Ingles Dietitian

Partner content: Post Hurricane

It is difficult to know what to write after a disaster of the magnitude caused by Hurricane Helene. It certainly teaches us the importance of coming together as a community to check on and help our friends and neighbors, and how vital our emergency response teams, first responders, National Guard, churches, shelters for both humans and animals, and relief organizations are in times like this.